She won her first national title at the age of 15, in 1980, and then took the European silver medal two years later, before finally winning the first of six successive golds in 1983.
Meanwhile, on the other side of the Iron Curtain, Sumners was developing an almost eerily parallel career, and was world champion by the time Sarajevo came around. Also competing for the US was the 1982 world champion Elaine Zayak. The stage was set in Yugoslavia for a classic Olympic sporting showdown.
Sumners began well, coming first in the compulsory figures, leaving Witt trailing in third. But Witt, dressed in a German folk costume, took a narrow lead in the short programme after Sumners was beset by minor technical errors.
The competition in the Zetra Arena came to a climax with the free programme, worth 50 per cent of the total score. Witt, an instinctive, elegant skater whose style has been described as “poetry in motion,” snatched victory from Sumners, the favourite, who held back on two of her triple jumps.
Witt’s boldness paid off, as she captured the imagination of the judges, six of whom gave her first-places, and won gold by the slimmest of margins. After her triumph the young, beautiful doyenne of the ice reportedly received more than one million letters from adoring fans – which perhaps inspired her to win her first world championship title that same year.
She defended that title the following year and claimed a third in 1987. At the Winter Games in Calgary, Canada, the following year Witt was favourite to take gold, with a new American rival, Debi Thomas, chasing at her heels, setting the scenes for another high stakes clash on the ice.
By coincidence both Witt and Thomas chose the same piece of music from Bizet’s opera Carmen for their long programme. After the compulsory figures and the short programme, they were in first and second place. After Witt downgraded a triple loop, Thomas was in prime position to win gold, but she missed three of her jumps – leaving Witt to defend her 1984 gold successfully.
After turning professional in 1988, Witt made an Olympic comeback at Lillehammer in 1994, finishing seventh in the figure skating competition, where she skated to Where Have all the Flowers Gone, signaling a message of peace to Sarajevo, by that time in the midst of a shattering Balkan war.